Thanks a lot for the great tips. Yep I know a lot of these concepts but really struggle to implement them :/
Size is the first problem. I usually go to big and quickly run into the second problem there -> dead space... I often have no idea how to litter up all this space ^^
If I go to small I can't really express my idea.
That's what I'm struggling with the most.
Usually I start thinking about what type of location I want my mini to be in. A forest, a street in a city, in a ruin, on a mountain ...
Then I look at reference. Problem with reference is that in reality or illustrations space isn't a problem. In painting you can express a forest with a path surrounded by dozens of trees and plants. If I want to translate that to a smaller base (fitting to the mini) I have to reduce the space. So when the mini for example walks a forest trail, the trail itself would probably to big for the base not to mention surrounding trees. So I struggle to translate what defines a forest on a really small space. A cut-out of a muddy trail with some leaves and mushrooms on the ground would probably be what I'ld end up with following this example. ^^ But that could be anywhere. Forest is just one example, mountain is even worse^^
I don't really know how to cook down a scene to its core. What really defines it and makes it recogniseable even on a small "cut-out" piece.
Also struggle with filling in details and randomness. I think I overthink where to put things and how they could have ended up there.
So yeah:
Randomness - don't be too concerned on making everything make sense, or straight, or perfectly positioned.
And last but not least I hate mixing putty, making a mess with it and waiting hours for it to dry xD
I usually sink dozens of hours into painting a mini but I usually want the base to be finished in just a couple of hours max^^
Maybe I just need some sucess moments to start enjoying building bases and display plinths xD
Since I suck at it, it feels more like a chore to me.
That's why I start to think it is probably better to try to draw inspiration from (or outright copy) other mini bases/plinths/dioramas instead of illustrations (like magic the gathering lands).