something is wrong here in cmon

Orb

procrastinator
Originally posted by Spacemunkie
*Very tiny voice*

\"NOBODY expets the miniature Inquisition!\"

lol

lollollol

**falls off chair**

\"our chief weapon is a computer, a computer and the T10L7....our two chief weapons are..............\"


\"Cardinal Spacemunkie..........read the charges\"
 

Spacemunkie

New member
Originally posted by borg
...not be so worried about fowlplay.

Ducks? Geese? Where?

And why are they having all the fun!

\"Our THREE chief weapons are a computer, the T10L7, a duck and a chicken....\"
 

EricJ

New member
Originally posted by Orb
I thought it was interesting that Seiya was the person that bought Robius to our attention here. Actually this thread is well worth another read!

Only 5 posts and 2 questioning votes!!! Now there\'s a suspicious person!

could be the alter-ego of a forum regular who they use to bring up stuff like this? We all know that questioning voting can go wrong fast. Either that or just a concerned, but generally passive forum-member

As for this mini, to me it definately looks like something inflated the vote count and score. As for the vote count it really isn\'t unprecidented however, I think my Dragyri had 200 votes in the first 48 hours just from being posted on cmon and jenovas (I think it went \"live\" on cmon at about 175 votes already). As for the score, I think probably theories about forums full of fanboys could be true.

However I also agree with spacemunkie, that scores generally are based on photos here, and these photos are very small, you can see distortions from the image compression, they don\'t look like levels were fixed giving it a much duller look that I expect it has in real life.

Oh well, it seems however though, that the regular members votes are starting to catch up with it and it\'s starting to drop.
 

dauber22

New member
Couldn\'t put it any better than this:

Originally posted by borg
Since this topic has come up a couple of times recently, let me put in my 2 cents.

Popular people get more votes. Yes, people that link their work from forums and from websites will get more votes. Just like any other product in the World, you are competing against almost 60,000 images for attention, anything that you do to make your work stand out will receive more attention.

Popular miniatures or miniature lines will get more votes. People need to identify with what they are voting on most of the time, so if you are painting whats hot at the moment, ie, GW, Rackham, WM etc, most likely you will get more attention.

Popular techniques will get more votes. If you paint in a style that is currently popular, ie, NMM, rusty metal, freehand, you will get more votes.

There are many other reasons. I have said it before, CMON is what it is - Cool Mini Or Not. What is a cool mini to one might not be to another. You might like the paintjob, the sculpt, the conversion or even the painter, that is all up to you.

If someone gets a lot of votes, great! So a lot of people like something that you don\'t. Well, you might have different taste. If we all like exactly the same thing, then we will all be wearing the same clothes, driving the same car and marrying the same girl lol Try to be happy for somebody who is getting the appreciation and not be so worried about fowlplay.

To be honest, there are tens of thousands of people on this site, if everyone would just vote, then there is no amount of sniping or inflating that anyone can do anyways... just a thought.

Just thought this was so well put, I\'d repost it :D
 

ipaintminis

New member
really?

apparentally I am just to nice....

I didnt even think of this

I do believe I am going to go back in my little corner, cover my ears and sing *there are good people* over and over again and stick with my \"they are a lurker\" persepective.
 

QuietiManes

New member
I dont think anyone should worry about getting a 1 one time. I dont much care about the voting system myself, I try to vote accordingly nowadays but in the past I\'d have 3-4 browsers going and just vote 1\'s to get through the pics as fast as possible. Or 5\'s or 10\'s or whatever I felt like at the time.

Quite often I\'d do 1\'s though, because there was a theory at the time that the system didnt take into account the votes that were way out of character from the current score. I.E. any vote more than about 2 points out from the current score wouldnt be taken into account. And when is anything under a 4.0? If it is, a 1 isnt going to make much difference anyway. So it seemed safe and fast for me to do...

I mean, in my defense, the voting system seem to be more about stroking E-peen than anything else and I\'m not into that really. As for the people that try to learn to improve and such, I dont have much to offer by way of advice, even if I did, there\'s tonnes of others on this site with better experience and advice. Lastly, one vote wont make much difference, a few bad \"1\" voters like I used to be would even out the +1 or +2 or strait \"10\'s\" the posters friends would vote, or so I thought. Either way, I put half an effort into voting now, hence I\'ll NEVER get through this massive pile of pictures lol
 

Ritual

New member
Seems like a waste of time to \'get through\' all the minis on this site if you\'re only giving everyone 1\'s and don\'t even spend time to look at the minis! ??? :rolleyes:
 

EricJ

New member
I agree with Ritual, seems like you take some satisfaction in having gotten through and voted on all the minis here (even if it was mindlessly voting without even looking at the photos)...seem no less relevant that someone else takes satisfaction from working hard and improving their scores here on cmon. (to me this actually seems much more relevant)

I mean you spent all that time to make your little vote count number go up, which indicates nothing more than you wasted time to do it (judging by your post). Yet you criticise someone else for working hard to make their score numbers go up, when that is actually an indication of their developing skill in their chosen hobby?

That seems to me like you\'ve developed a bit of a skewed perspective.
 

Fizl

Secret Crocodile
Got to ask a stupid question (as someone who has voted on all the figures on the site) what is i-peen? Is this like i-ego? If not I\'m worried about what I\'ve been stroking!

Shaz
 

Infidel Castro

New member
My god this has blown over night lol

The Knights of the Fair Score shall ride forth and clash with armies of Snipe and Fanboy. There shall be much blood shed this day.
 

Ritual

New member
Originally posted by reverend
The Knights of the Fair Score shall ride forth and clash with armies of Snipe and Fanboy. There shall be much blood shed this day.
Yeah, we\'re gonna get them good!!! :rolleyes:
 

finn17

New member
Hmmm..

The voting pattern on this mini is definitely unusual, but not if you factor in the \'fan effect\'. That\'s democracy in action folks....think of it as \'party politics\'.
Besides, anyone who takes the CMON voting system too seriously is going to get upset at some point. But we\'ve said this before....
 
Back To Top
Top