Mistakes in movies..

Dragonsreach

Super Moderator
LOTR: ROTK
Classic error in the long shot scene showing Eowyn waiting at Edoras the smoke is going down the chimneys and Flags are wafting in reverse. lol
 
Orginal gepostet von Ritual
LOTR: FOTR - When Arwen races for the fords of Bruinen there\'s a very short close up of her and Frodo and you can clearly see Frodo is a doll who looks lifeless and NOTHING like Elijah Wood.

Gladiator - When one of the Gladiator chariots is smashed during the large battle re-enactment you can see some sort of engine or pneumatic device in it.

Sleepy Hollow - Johnny Depp writes down notes in his notebook and you see a close-up when he writes \'Balthus van Tassel\'. Then you see the name in close-up again and the handwriting is slightly different. Later you see the page for a third time and then it\'s yet another writing.

My all-time favourite mistake must be in the old Spartacus when one of the gladiator slaves has a wrist watch. lol

So are you saying that Elijah Wood is anything but lifeless in LOTR (any) ? :eek:
 

vincegamer

New member
Originally posted by Einion
[General complaints: one thing that movies (Enemy Of The State) and TV (CSI) do constantly, which grates on me no end, is the apparent infinite resolution of surveillance-camera recordings (no matter how crappy the camera is in some cases!) allowing them to blow an image up and get a reflection off an eyeball (!) or some such nonsence.
This reminds me of Blade Runner where they zoom in on the photo then actually turn around the corner into another room!
 

vincegamer

New member
Originally posted by Sithtainius
Originally posted by Einion

The power of bullets is so often exaggerated out of all proportion but you just have to accept it as a stylistic thing, although in realistic movies it\'s grating.


the flip side of that is that they\'re just as often under-powered. how many times have you seen the hero or bad guy hide behind a car or car door? the bullet would go right through the door and still get \'em....
Not to mention movie handguns never seem to have kickback.
 

Rhode

New member
I believe theres a car/train in Lord of the Rings episode I. The scene where frodo and sam walk in the corn field together, theres something far behind them...
 

Flightless

New member
Got another couple of Matrix ones for you:

The interrogation scene. You know the drill, little green room etc.
After Neo\'s mouth gets sealed shut, and he\'s getting a little annoyed about it, it cuts back to our dear Agent Smith. In whose wodnerfully shiny glasses we can see Neo sitting in his general defiant pose, as earlier.

And another, this time earlier in the film just to confuse you people:
The very first chase scene, over the rooftops with Trinity. There is a gap. It is jumped. The policeman who jumps badly and hits the wall manages (and i think this is impressive on a brick wall) to make it wobble. Turn the speed down and this is nicely visible.

Pff, all films are full of them, the Matrix trilogy notably so (standard realism issues aside [mostly], i wouldn\'t expect a metal pole to bend quite that much when swung. Wood, sure.) Doesn\'t stop a decent level of enjoyment.
Usually.
 

supervike

Super Moderator
\"Three Men and a Baby\" was rumoured to have a ghost of a dead boy in one of the scenes. I can remember renting the VCR tape and going frame by frame through that scene. It was very creepy. Long afterwards, we found that it was a cheap cardboard cutout of Ted Dansen, left mistakenly by the window...

3menghost.jpg





There was that one time in Star Wars where R2D2 says \"Beep-boop-boop-beep-beep beep\" which translates roughly to \"C3PO, you couldn\'t be more gay if you were wearing assless leather chaps\"

Lucas left it in the Special Edition Version.
 

Einion

New member
Originally posted by Sithtainius
the flip side of that is that they\'re just as often under-powered. how many times have you seen the hero or bad guy hide behind a car or car door? the bullet would go right through the door and still get \'em....
Not necessarily but yes, often they would.

Nerdy gun-fan time: apart from what I\'m about to say, the gun, the bullet type, the range and the angle of the surface to the incoming shot would all have some effect. But car doors vary a great deal from place to place in how much protection they provide - the glass, the winding mechanism, the lock etc. Assuming a nearly-perpendicular shot to a part of the door where there is no internal mechanism you\'re talking about a single layer of mild steel and some plastic, so yeah, even just handgun bullets can whiz right through.

Originally posted by steelcult
If I know the episode of CSI your speaking of I think the image in questions was supposed to have been taken with a pro level digital or film camera. The thing that got me about it was that all they had to resolve was the print, not the negative.
I was a digital camera I\'m pretty sure... given the size of the subject in the frame they\'d have had to have been looking at a 60 megapixel image or something like that to even think of trying this!

If they did use a print to do something like this in another episode :rolleyes:

Originally posted by Dragonsreach
LOTR: ROTK
Classic error in the long shot scene showing Eowyn waiting at Edoras the smoke is going down the chimneys and Flags are wafting in reverse. lol
Oh classic! Didn\'t spot that. You see this sometimes in shots with water (waterfall in one scene of Anaconda).

Originally posted by vincegamer
Not to mention movie handguns never seem to have kickback.
That is generally true, that or just very little - with no bullet being spit out the end of the barrel there\'s no transfer of mementum as there would be normally.

Originally posted by Flightless
After Neo\'s mouth gets sealed shut, and he\'s getting a little annoyed about it, it cuts back to our dear Agent Smith. In whose wodnerfully shiny glasses we can see Neo sitting in his general defiant pose, as earlier.
Ah, good one, I remember that now. This is what digital post-processing is for Bros. Wachowski!

Originally posted by Flightless
The policeman who jumps badly and hits the wall manages (and i think this is impressive on a brick wall) to make it wobble. Turn the speed down and this is nicely visible.
Wobbly parts of the set, I love it! And here\'s us thinking it was just in Plan 9 From Outer Space lol

Related to this, in an early episode of Enterprise Archer is in a Jeffries tube or something like that and you can clearly see the metal panel behind him has a plywood grain texture under the paint!

Originally posted by Flightless
standard realism issues aside [mostly], i wouldn\'t expect a metal pole to bend quite that much when swung. Wood, sure.
Well he is Neo and there is no pole... lol Actually you can bend sign posts a smidgen by hand, never made one shake by giving it a smack when you walk past? Oh, that\'s just me isn\'t it! You can even get some lampposts to wobble :)

Einion
 

vincegamer

New member
Originally posted by EinionWobbly parts of the set, I love it! And here\'s us thinking it was just in Plan 9 From Outer Space lol
Well, you mustn\'t forget the famous scene in Goldfinger when Oddjob throws his hat at the marble statue and cuts off the head. Even at regular speed it\'s quite clear that the head begins to fall off before the hat hits it.
 

Shawn R. L.

New member
In Blade Runner there is a scene where Harrison Ford takes a fish scale to a fellow to have it identified. The fellow puts it under a microscope and what is viewed ( I had a book of electorn microscope pictures with that very picture in it) was a electorn microscope picture of a pot leaf.
 

Swordwind

New member
Originally posted by KingM
I know a good LotR one, in the scene where Faramir finds out Frodo has the ring (in some caverns). There are these big barrels behind the hobbits, then in the next shot they randomly disappear.

Also, there is a bit of scripting weirdness, at one point Arwen says \"The light of the Evenstar does not wax away\", but wax is to grow more powerful right? wane is to diminish

She does say Wax and Wane.

In King Arthur when Lancelot is being taken from his village his mother keeps swapping which of his shoulders she is standing behind.
 

Ogrebane

New member
In Brave heart the fight scence were he went to oic a fight. he starts running with a claymore, next shot a military pick back to the two handed sword then no weapon then pick and finally two handed sword again.

Or in the final scene where the ax heads are swaying in the breeze.
 

Einion

New member
Originally posted by Ritual
Here\'s everything you need to know (and a LOT more) about mistakes in movies:
http://www.moviemistakes.com/
It\'s a good start but since the entries are submitted by members they\'re full of errors (just like the \'quotes\' on IMDb) and some are not even mistakes in any true sense. As for it being comprehensive if you check you\'ll see some of those listed above are not in it! :)

Originally posted by Modderrhu
Geez, poor guy! Does Trinity know about this little, uhm... problem? ??? lol
lol lol lol

Einion
 

freakinacage

New member
you can kinda see the wires when neo backflips out of the path of the subway train in the first one. and you can see the camera lense in the closeup of the doorknob when they visit the oracle
 

sniffles

New member
I always find it amusing to watch for alternate uses of everyday items in sci-fi movies. One of my favorites is actually not in a movie but an episode of Star Trek - The Next Generation, where Wesley Crusher had some nanites (nanobots) in a container. I had to laugh when I realized the container was a 35mm film developing canister with some yellow tape on it to make it look \"futuristic\".
lol
I like Einion\'s comments about the image enhancement on shows like CSI. They used to do that all the time on The X-Files too. I always laugh when they blow up some photo or video image to enormous proportions and yet the pixel/grain resolution remains perfectly fine. I also get very amused with all the other unrealistic stuff they do on CSI, like having the investigators do suspect interviews, or go back to the crime scene half a dozen times; and having their very own DNA lab right there in the police station.
lol
 

vincegamer

New member
Originally posted by sniffles
I always find it amusing to watch for alternate uses of everyday items in sci-fi movies.
Haven\'t you heard the story from the original Star Trek series?

For the Salt Vampire episode they sent the prop crew out to find futuristic looking salt shakers. They came back with a large selection of odd salt shakers. Rodenberry thought they were too odd and the audience would not immediately recognize them as salt shakers so they just went to the comissary and got some ordinary shakers for the scene.

So what did they do with the \"futuristic\" salt shakers? They became McCoy\'s medical kit. Every time he waves that small \"medical tricorder\" over a patient I laugh because he\'s salting his patient!

p.s. This thread got under my skin. I was watching a bit of Wayne\'s World on TV this weekend and I kept noticing things like when he swordfights his girlfriend\'s father he slices up his pants and immediately they aren\'t sliced anymore, but ... it\'s Wayne\'s World so it wasn\'t really a mistake was it?
 

Naukhel

New member
You all are snickering about the image enhancements in CSI... but go much farther back, to the movie Blow Up...

A photographer takes a picture in a park, and when he looks at it later, thinks he sees a part of a body sticking out from under a bush, or something... so he enlarges the picture to nearly a wall-sized poster... several times... focusing on a small area of the original photo... and it never loses resolution.

And this is before computer assisted enhancements...
 
Back To Top
Top