Close Combat
Since you were looking for Close Combat, the Harlies beat the Spears hands down (IMHO):innocent:.
But if you want the hit and run with emphasis on the HIT :flame:go with the Spears.
Like most of the Eldar Pantheon, it really depends quite specifically on your style of play and the tactics you employ.
In my experience, when sticking your neck out to try something new with the pointy-eared ones, expect to get your head lopped off a couple times at first, but pay attention to what did and didn\'t work and you should iron your tactics into a finely-honed blade of prwecision and grace, ...kind of fitting...