The only religious figures I can think of that Reaper\'s done are its
Angel of Mercy,
Angel of Light,
Angel of Peace, and
Cupid and Cherubs.
Here\'s a link to Thunderbolt Mountain\'s
Nativity miniatures. It looks like there are plans to expand to include the Magi and some other pieces, but I\'m pretty sure I saw that same statement on the page a year ago, so who knows when.
I think the idea of looking for something suitable through religious outlets rather than miniature ones is a good one. You might even try the dollar store. I\'m not at all religious, but I did a couple of searches to see what I could come up with and found some prospects.
Rawcliffe is a company that does collectible pewter. They even take some Reaper sculpts, add crystals and antique them up a little and sell those. They have a nice though expensive
full Nativity scene. They also have a nice angel in the Pewter Ornaments section and a selection of religious themed pendants. I also found a site with
Mexican pewter, and loads of places with religious pewter charms. I just did a quick search on \'pewter religious\'.