Cross-Manufacturer Game?

Fuseboy

New member
Anyone know a good, skirmish-level miniatures game that lets you use miniatures from any manufacturer (i.e. by having good, balanced rules for unit creation and costing)?

These days, I paint more than I play, and most of my recent gaming has been Warmaster. I like the strategy, but the tiny 10mm miniatures aren\'t as rewarding to paint as 25-30mm miniatures.

I find myself looking for a way to take my favourite painted miniatures (from various manufacturers) and making a small skirmish band out of them. Bands of adventurers, a motley collection of monsters, a lance of elven mercenaries, etc. The games games I\'ve played that have good mechanics (e.g. LOTR), however, don\'t have unit costing rules.

Many recent games have rules that are freely downloadable (e.g. CAV, Confrontation, Dark Age, Celtos, Warchest, Mage Knight) are available as free downloads, which implies to me that it\'s all about selling lead. Perhaps army books don\'t sell as well without a retail presence, but few gaming shops are going to maintain a good supply of miniatures for such a variety of games.

The main problem is the mutual incompatability of the games, combined with the effort it takes to get ready to play. It\'s one thing to pick up a chess set, it\'s another to buy an army Rackham and paint it.

It seems that there\'s a logical place for a set of rules that\'s agnostic to the miniature manufacturer. Anyone else know what I\'m talking about?
 

Dragonsreach

Super Moderator
Fuseboy:
Anyone know a good, skirmish-level miniatures game that lets you use miniatures from any manufacturer (i.e. by having good, balanced rules for unit creation and costing)?
Yes. Area51 in Harbinger magazine issue 2. Only the Greys are based from Griffon miniatures, you can please yourself for the rest.
 

Taer

New member
I tend to look at a mini and say, \"Hmmm, I know this isn\'t a LOTR mini, but what LOTR type guy fits him the best?\" I do this for most games, so I end up with really assorted armies, and they tend to recycle minis from one game/army to the next. :flip::bouncy:
 

Impernouncable

New member
Hellion Productions\' Hellion science fiction rules are based on 1/60 scale and are intentionally generic. I can\'t vouch for the quality though. They also make two 1/60 scale resin CAVs under licence from Reaper Miniatures. VOR the Maelstrom, while it did have its own figures, also included rules for designing your own troop profiles for any models you like. I think it\'s currently out of print, but the licenses for all of FASA\'s games were picked up by Hobby Products and WizKidz, so it may resurface at some point.

IMO the whole thing is moot. Find a rule set you like and make up an army list for the figures you like. Be smart, be fair, and try your best to make a ballanced list, even if it means sacrificing some degree of \"coolness.\"
 

Sand Rat

New member
Try Iron Winds of War from Iron Winds - Fantasy Skirmish in 25-30 mm with unit costing rules. Five and a half pages long when I downloaded it and that includes the updates (the rules are 20 + yrs old)
 

Flashman14

New member
If I may ....

Why not try historicals? What you describe doesn\'t exist at all in that branch of the hobby . . .

Brother v Brother, Sword & The Flame, GASLIGHT, etc etc
 
Back To Top
Top