A 5.8?? Geez, tough crowd here. The face is done exquisitely. The horn looks fantastic as well. I realise the LOTR characters are kind of monochromatic, but some stronger color would have been nice. Perhaps up the highlights on the clothing too. I think that's why the score is so low. Great stuff otherwise!
A nice clean paint job, but with little to distinguish it. I realize its hard with the LotR minis since you want them to look like the movie, but he's all black! Could use some different colors...